Fixed Deposit vs Mutual Fund: Meaning, Risk, Liquidity & Taxation
A Former User last edited by ftForumMod
Fixed Deposit vs Mutual fund is a difficult comparison. We compare FD and Mutual Funds based on return, risk profile, investment horizon and other factors. Both of them are very different products and each has its own advantages and disadvantages.
Fixed Deposit Meaning:
Fixed Deposit (FD) are saving tools offered by banks to deposit lump sum amount for a fixed period of time on a higher interest rate than saving accounts. The interest rate offered on fixed deposits are compounded quarterly and is a risk-free saving instrument.
The tenure of fixed deposit varies from 7 days to 10 years. The interest rate offered is less for shorter duration and increases gradually for the longer duration.
Mutual Funds Meaning:
Mutual funds are investment products which pool money from numerous small investors to create a fund. The amount is invested in equity and debt instruments of companies with promising future outlook for superior return in long term period.
Mutual funds are a common choice for those investors who don't have much knowledge on stocks market or don't have the time track the market. Investment in mutual funds are considered riskier than FD and returns are subject to market volatility. It brings professional management of funds.
FD vs Mutual Funds: Risk profile
Fixed Deposit is risk-free saving instruments and is not affected by any macroeconomic event or RBI policy. There is no effect of a change in monetary policy by RBI on existing fixed deposits.
Mutual Funds carry risk on investment. Different fund type has different categories of risk. Like Equity funds contains higher risk than Balanced Funds and Balanced Funds are riskier than Debt funds. There are various risk factors in a Mutual fund, like:
- Market Risk
- Sectoral Risk
- Interest Rate Risk
- Company Risk
- Fund Manager Risk
FD vs Mutual Funds: Returns
Returns from fixed deposits are fixed. Interest rate of fixed deposit depends on the Repo rate, CRR, liquidity in the system. If the RBI decides to decrease Repo rate then all the new Fixed deposit that will be issued will have less interest rate. The increase in liquidity in the system also decreases the rates for FDs.
Whereas returns from a well managed mutual fund outperform the fixed deposit return by a huge margin of 10-12 percentage points over the long term. Equity mutual fund return depends on market performance and portfolio performance of the fund. Debt mutual fund's return depends on the Interest rate, interest income, and liquidity.
Fixed Deposit vs Mutual Funds: Investment Horizon
Fixed Deposits have a maturity period of deposit ranging from 7 days to maximum of 10 years. Depositors choose their maturity period depending on their fund requirements and maximum interest rate being offered in that time slab.
Investment in mutual funds is suitable for the long term period of more than 5 years to 10 years. The longer time frame will help in the compounding of investment, factor in market volatility of price and better return. Those investors with an investment horizon of short-term duration can invest in short-term debt funds suitable for 1-3 years of investment.
FD vs Mutual fund: Liquidity
Liquidity in Fixed deposit doesn't come free of cost. If a person decides to withdraw the FD amount before maturity period, then he has to pay penalty and is charged from the final amount.
Mutual funds are considered highly liquid fund. Investment redeemed before 1 year has to pay exit load of 1%. The exit load and time frame depend from fund to fund. Investment unit redeemed after one year are not charged with exit load and full value is paid to the investor.
FD vs Mutual Funds: How to Invest?
Fixed deposit are generally lump sum and one-time investment done in the bank and is linked through Saving bank account.
Investment in Mutual funds is done in two ways, either lump sum or SIP. In lump sum or one time you invest in the particular fund at a price (NAV). In Systematic Investment Plan (SIP), one can invest a small amount of money periodically into the selected mutual fund. (For example: If you select 20th of every month the Rs 1000 will be invested into the selected fund on that day's NAV)
FD & Mutual Fund: Taxation
The interest that you receive on fixed deposit, TDS is applicable on it. So, the actual return from the Fixed deposit is much less than the interest rate of FD.
Mutual Funds enjoy the benefits of taxation for long term investment. Taxation of different fund types are discussed below.
Tax obligation for investment in equity mutual fund (those fund with equity portfolio of more than 65%)
- For period of more than one year: Earlier the Long term Capital Gain used to be tax free. But, now tax @10% on LTCG shall be applicable if gains exceed Rs.1 lakh in a financial year.
- For less than 1 year equity funds are taxed 15% short term capital gains tax.
For Debt funds, investment for a period of 1-3 years are considered short term and it is taxed @ 10% and for more than 3 years, it is taxed 20% with the benefit of indexation.
Fixed Deposits vs Mutual Funds: Conclusion
Fixed Deposits seem to a traditional and a great option for saving money. FDs are good to protect your money from depreciation over the long term due to inflation. Fixed deposits are suitable in short term period as the investment in a short-term mutual fund with low-risk grade also gives same return. However, these may not be suitable for long-term wealth creation.
On the other hand, Mutual fund investment benefits in longer duration based on various factors like above average return, taxation benefit, liquidity. Further, the easy and convenient investment method like Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) usually attracts investors.
Meghna last edited by
@navya FDs are losing their shine these days. The interest rate is not so high. Then tax is deducted. So, what we get in hand is too less. Inflation rate is so high and I don't think FDs are an ideal choice. What do you think? Am I correct in my thinking? We need to look for different investments to earn better.
Nishtha last edited by ftForumMod
Fixed deposits are popular investment options offered by banks. You can deposit money for a better rate of interest as compared to savings accounts. It can be a lump sum deposit of money in fixed deposits for a particular period, which could range from 7 days to 10 years.
Once you invest the money with a reliable financier, it begins earning an interest depending on the duration of the deposit. Generally, the basic defining criteria for FD is that the money invested cannot be withdrawn before maturity, however, you could withdraw after you pay a penalty.
What are the features of FDs?
Following are the Key features of FDs:
- Offer stability
- There is no risk of loss of principal
- The market fluctuations do not affect your FDs
- The interest rates are higher
What is a mutual fund?
A mutual fund is formed when capital collected from different investors is invested in company shares, stocks or bonds. Shared by thousands of investors like you, a mutual fund is managed collectively to earn the maximum possible returns.
The total corpus of money that builds up is invested in various asset classes of any type, be it debt funds, liquid assets etc. The principle feature of mutual funds is that exactly like gains and rewards that are earned over the period of investment are shared by the investors in equal proportion, the losses are too.
The distribution is done in accordance with their ratio of the contribution made in the corpus.
What are the Types of Mutual Funds?
The money in the funds is well regulated by SEBI, or the Securities and Exchange Board of India. They are generally of five types:
- Equity funds
- Debt funds
- Balanced funds
- Solution-oriented funds
- Hybrid funds
Anmol last edited by
@nishtha Hi, I feel these days mutual funds can give far better return than old age methods of investing in FDs. My parents insist me to put money in FD. But, I prefer exploring different investing ways. I know there is risk attached to these mutual funds. FD is a very safe option. But, still I would like to try and earn better through mutual funds. What do you think?
Deepti last edited by
@anmol I agree with your point. Even I feel returns on FDs is very less. You get a reduced in hand amount after TDS. So, the FD interest rate that you see isn't what you actually get.
Punkeirang last edited by
But fixed good old deposits are still an option and are almost risk free. Why don't you make it like it's nothing with mutual funds you mututally gain or mutually loose. Yes, FD have taxes, not that high as it was rates and so on. But it should still be an option and always will be. Your parents know life and are correct about that.
Guest last edited by
@Punkeirang Absolutely agreed, fixed deposits should definitely still be a part of one's portfolio. How much though is a question that people need to decide based on their risk apetite !
Girish Khanna last edited by ftForumMod
@Punkeirang Yes, FD is an age old investing method. My parents had saved all money in FDs only. I too believe we should have some FDs made for our retirement. These days the younger generation is more inclined towards taking risks. So, keep on suggesting to invest in mutual funds etc. I am satisfied with earning 7-8% interest on FD. And, there's no risk to lose the money.
Karan Kapoor last edited by
@Girish Khanna @Punkeirang I think FD is a good option for Senior citizens since they get a good interest rate plus some extra tax saving benefit also. But, for others the interest rate you are saying 7-8% is not the actual rate. This is before tax rate. And, more interest is offered for long term FDs.
Also, the real rate of return is much lesser after taxes. So, you basically get lesser in hand amount.